cheesy bacon toasts

Listen up, people! Do I ever have a good eat for you! It’s the three basic food groups—bacon! cheese! bread!—smashed into one amazing, delectable, and utterly satisfying food. Behold…

Cheesy bacon toasts!

Okay, so its appearance is a bit anticlimactic, I admit. White cheese on white bread and it doesn’t even look very gooey. In fact, it looks dry. Ha! Too bad you can’t taste the picture. Or even just smell it. One whiff and you’d all be digging through your freezers in frantic search of that leftover pack of bacon you just know you have in there somewhere…

I got this recipe from Ruth Reichl’s blog. You know, only the woman who routinely eats the fanciest and most expensive food in the world. When fancy people post simple recipes, I listen. And you should too.

Ruth says these toasts make wonderful appetizers and, to go with the fancy appetizer motif, she gets all trim-the-crusts-off elegant. To which—both the appetizer and the crust-trimming—I say, bah. This is main dish, hearty fare, and the crusts stay on. We common folk like both quantity and crusts, thank you very much.

To make these toasts, just toss raw bacon, cheese, onion, and horseradish in a bowl, mound the cheese mixture on pieces of bread, and pop them into the oven to bake.

The first time I made these toasts, I was worried about two things. One, that the bacon grease would run off my un-sided baking sheets and smoke up the oven, and two, that the tops of the bread would get toasty while the undersides remained soggy-soft.

I needn’t have worried. See, as the toasts bake, the bacon juices seep down into the bread which leads to this fabulous (and very tidy) trick in which the bread actually fries in the bacony juices. This, in turn, transforms the toasts’ raw underbellies into a golden brown and crispy crust. The result is nothing less than toasted perfection.

Cheesy Bacon Toasts 
Adapted from Ruth Reichl’s blog.

These toasts pair wonderfully with any soup or salad. Or how about alongside a pan of eggs? Here’s a crazy idea: two toasts smashed together with a hamburger patty in the middle! Or eat them all by themselves for a quick dinner, perhaps with a glass of wine. Really, any time, any place. Bonus: leftovers make a kicker breakfast.

The horseradish is imperative. I used an extra-sharp white cheddar, which I loved, but next time I might add some mozzarella or Havarti to increase the goo factor. Keep in mind that bacon is easier to dice when still mostly frozen.

Measurements are loosey-goosey. Feel free to play!

6 thin slices of sourdough (or your favorite) bread
6 ounces sharp cheddar cheese, grated
4 ounces frozen bacon, chopped small
¼ to ½ cup minced onion
1 tablespoon drained horseradish
salt and pepper

Put the slices of bread on a baking sheet. In a bowl, stir together the bacon with the onion, horseradish, a pinch of salt, and some black pepper. Add the cheese and toss to combine. Distribute the cheese mixture over the pieces of bread. Bake at 350 degrees for 20 minutes. Cut toasts into quarters and serve warm.

This same time, years previous: eight, seven, travel tips, gourmet chocolate bark, on babies, dear Mom, ice cream cake, lemon tart, and potatoes with roasted garlic vinaigrette.


  • JustCallMeBetty

    I just finished making these. My suggestion for everyone is to double or even triple the recipe because they are going to disappear quick!

    I did not have any horseradish so I used Dijon mustard and I put the mixture on sliced rounds of a baguette

  • Christine

    Cannot thank you enough for this recipe. As we hunkered down for the frigid cold & snow in Northern Virginia, these were fabulous with our big pot of Chorizo and Kale Soup. Stay warm!

  • Anonymous

    Comfort food from my childhood! Only skip the onion and horseradish, mound the cheese-butter mixture on the bread and top with a partially cooked slice of bacon and a ribbon of ketchup before baking. My mom used to make these for evening coffee time refreshments with guests–1940s pizza, maybe!

  • Margo

    wow these look great and so clever! I can get ground bacon at my market – would it make sense to use that, or should I use chopped bacon like you say? Definitely making these.

Leave a Comment