Soups made from squash (or pumpkin) have forever eluded me. I’ve experimented with a variety of recipes over the years—in 2008 I even posted the rough outline of a curry soup—but over all I’ve always found them lacking. It’s like they’re too one dimensional in their thick creaminess. Or something. Even when tasty, they’re kind of boring. Plus, I find it pretty hard to ignore the bothersome fact that a bowl of squash soup looks an awful lot like a bowl of lamb poo.
Which is a shame, because, what with that creamy texture and bland agree-ability, squashes and pumpkins seem like they ought to be perfect key players for soup. It’s just that I’ve never managed to hit upon the right wow factor.
Until a couple weekends ago, that is, when my aunt hosted her annual fall soiree and served us a squash soup that stole the show. And it was a good show, too! Curried beef and veggies, rice, lentils, cucumbers in yogurt, na’an, and so on. But that soup! Talk about Wow!
I wasn’t the only one impressed. In the following weeks, my mother made it, and my cousin, too. It took me a little longer, but I finally got around to it. And good news! It was exactly as wonderful as I remembered.
The soup itself is really nothing fancy (though the coconut milk adds nice oomph): like any other squash soup, it’s good, but predictable. It’s the corn relish that’s the kicker. Juicy from the fresh lime and pungent with cilantro, the barely-cooked kernels snap between your teeth, providing the perfect light counterpoint to the creamy squash. It’s an absolute marvel.
Winter Squash Soup with Corn Relish
Adapted from Epicurious (via my aunt), and title stolen from my cousin.
A word about the squash. My aunt used Calabaza. My mother and cousin used butternut. And I used Bertha, which was the name we gave to the Hubbard that a girlfriend lugged over to our house.
We roasted Bertha’s bottom half for pies, and then, a couple days later, roasted the top half for the soup. The remaining puree got stashed in the freezer for future Bertha creations. I had never cooked a hubbard before and I was pleasantly surprised by the whole experience.
My aunt used some chicken broth in place of water, but I stuck with plain water and didn’t notice a difference. Also, don’t skimp on the cilantro and lime; they are key players. I used frozen corn and didn’t even heat it up. If using fresh corn, boil it on the cob for a couple minutes.
for the soup:
1 glug olive oil
1 medium onion, chopped
¼ cup cilantro stems
2 cloves garlic, minced
6 cups roasted squash, roughly chopped/mashed
4 cups water
1 12-ounce can (or thereabouts) coconut milk
2 teaspoons salt (and probably a good bit more)
¼ teaspoon cayenne
Saute the onion in the olive oil. After five minutes or so, add the garlic and cilantro stems and saute for another several minutes. Add the remaining ingredients, heat through, and simmer on medium-low heat for 10 minutes or so. Puree with an immersion blender (or other kitchen gadget of your choice).
for the relish:
4½ teaspoons fresh lime juice (about 2 limes)
pinch of sugar
¼ teaspoon salt
2 tablespoons olive oil
1 tablespoon minced onion
2 tablespoons minced fresh cilantro
2 cups corn
Whisk together the lime juice, sugar, salt, and olive oil. Add the remaining ingredients and toss to combine.
Ladle the hot soup into a bowl and top with a generous spoonful of relish. Enjoy!
(Leftovers are fab. The relish holds up for days in the fridge.)
This same time, years previous: our cracking whip, random, the quotidian (10.22.12), a silly supper, aging, party panic, and apple tart with cider-rosemary glaze.
I am making this already for the second time. The kids love it. The relish is amazing, even after the soup is gone.
I made this for tonight's dinner with kabocha squash. A whole one was closer to five cups, so I reduced the water (but still added all the coconut milk). It is so delicious!
Made it. Loved it. Thank you! 🙂
This sounds delicious, thank you!
also I agree with thelmarose. Last week I probably drove your click counter way up checking and re-checking for a post on the soiree.
oh! suddenly remembered a squash soup that I made once with a topping of chopped cilantro, peanuts, and lime. That made the soup. Maybe the lesson here is that squash soups need a topping?
You're totally doing your aunt's soiree post right? Please do! I LOVE those posts.
Suggestions for what to use in place of the coconut milk? I would love to make this but really dislike anything coconut. Thanks!
The coconut is not a strong flavor, so you could probably substitute more water or a broth of some sort.
Totally making this!
I'm in….thanks for sharing. 🙂
I am a fan of winter squash soup, but the other people that live in my house? Not so much, for reasons similar to the ones you list here. I'm so trying this to see what they say. Thanks for sharing!